Fundamentally, there really is no such thing as “NB-IoT”. The correct term is “LTE Cat NB1”. This technology is sometimes confused with Cat-M, which is another misnomer. The correct name for “Cat M” is LTE Cat M1. Both these technologies, LTE Cat NB1 and LTE Cat M1 are just subsets of “classic LTE” and are a part of the 3GPP Release 13 fixed in June 2016.
Alphabet soup with LTE Cat NB1 and LTE Cat M1
Many people are aware of the Cat9 compatibility of the iPhone 7. LTE-Cat9 can support up to 450 MBit/s in theory in contrast with LTE Cat NB1 that offers only 20 Kbit/s. The name LTE Cat NB1 implies that it may be succeeded by a technology called LTE Cat NB2 or something similar. An NB2 would be possible since LTE base stations are software defined radios (SDR) and support this type of enhancement. The same is valid to LTE- Cat M1 – a version M2 can follow later on.
The 450 MBit/s on LTE-Cat9 have disadvantages and drawbacks in wireless IoT and M2M. A high speed will force a high calculation power and high-end digital signal processors (DSP). At LTE Cat NB1 and LTE Cat M1, we have the opposite. The complexity of the chipset is lower than at LTE Cat1. This will reduce costs. Moreover, the lower the communication speed on a radio the better the sensitivity of the receiver is. Just compare it with the data sheet of your Wi-Fi router at home. This is valid for all radio modules.
Wi-Fi receiver sensitivity for a typical Wi-Fi 802.11b/g client
Signal Strength (RSSI), Link Speed, Theoretical free space range (meter)
- -94 dBm 1 Mbps 1543
- -93 dBm 2 Mbps 1375
- -92 dBm 5.5 Mbps 1226
- -86 dBm 6 Mbps 614
- -86 dBm 9 Mbps 614
- -90 dBm 11 Mbps 974
- -86 dBm 12 Mbps 614
- -86 dBm 18 Mbps 614
- -84 dBm 24 Mbps 488
- -80 dBm 36 Mbps 308
- -75 dBm 48 Mbps 173
- -71 dBm 54 Mbps 109
At 54 Mbps the Wi-Fi signal will theoretical travel 109 meters in free space. At 1 Mbps the same device will reach 1543 meter.
– LTE-CAT NB1 and LTE CAT M1 are subsets of “classic LTE” only
– The sensitivity at LTE Cat NB1 and LTE Cat M1 is much higher than with an iPhone on Cat9
– The production costs for an LTE Cat NB1 or LTE Cat M1 chipsets are much cheaper
I will come back on my words and the words of my business friends soon. Not all of the are radio engineers. However, 50 billion connected things by 2020 will need a lot of embedded antennas because wired 50 billion connected things are impossible.
Do not hesitate to drop an email to harald.naumann (at) gsm-modem.de . I will be happy to support your wireless IoT / M2M project as well.
The lesson one was written for the IoT-University at Linkedin:
Thank you for the support to Joe Hubert from US. Joe is one of the first “students” at the IoT-University and supported me during writing my IoT/M2M Cookbook as well.